I distinctly remember being in fifth grade, and hanging on
the edge of my seat listening to my teacher read Beverly Cleary’s The Mouse and the Motorcycle. I simply could not wait until the next
chapter. Unfortunately, Ralph S. Mouse did not have the same
effect on me. It was a cute story but I
was bored from chapter one until the end at chapter nine.
Ralph, the mouse, lives in a hotel called the Mountain View
Inn where he enjoys riding his motorcycle.
Ralph has several relatives who have moved in to Mountain View Inn
because of the cold weather. This is bad news because these relatives are becoming a
problem for Ralph’s human-friend, Matt, who works at the Inn. Because he doesn’t want Matt to get in
trouble, Ralph decides to leave. Ralph
meets another human, Ryan, who takes him to his school. This is where Ralph elects to stay. What happens to Ralph when Ryan takes the
suggestion of his teacher to make Ralph his science project? What will happen to Ralph and his beloved motorcycle?
The nature of the conflict
of Ralph S. Mouse comes in different
varieties. While Ralph does struggle
with others, mainly his relatives who have moved into the Inn, he also
struggles with the society of Ryan’s classmates; thus creating multiple conflicts for Ralph. He experiences both person-against-person and person-against-society
in the story.
Beverly Cleary’s Ralph
S. Mouse would be a very appropriate book to discuss story elements with
students. Both the readability and
content are elementary and so any teacher could pick up this book to educate
students on elements of fiction such as plot, characters, setting, theme, and
style.
Big questions to ask students after reading Ralph S. Mouse: Why is it important to
Ralph that Matt not get in trouble at the Mountain View Inn? Why did Ryan take the suggestion of his
teacher to keep Ralph to show to his school?
I too remember reading this book as child and being on the edge of my seat with anticipation. As an elementary teacher, I agree that it would be a good animal fantasy book to read to students. However, I don't think I would choose to read it to my K students. I think the plot is more for 2nd-4th/5th grade readers. I agree this book lends itself to the teaching of story elements such as plot, theme, characters, setting, problem/solution, and style.
ReplyDeleteMy question is, if you were bored, why finish? Life it too short to read a book you don't like!
ReplyDelete